Critique Styles, Formats, and Expectations
Bill Baldwin
As writers, most of us understand the importance of critique groups—but how well do we actually understand their true use fulness and how they function? Did you know there are actually a variety of approaches to critique groups? Rebecca Gomez Farrell shared a wealth of useful information and insights at our June South Bay Writers meeting. Why join a critique group? You can improve your craft and get help when you get stuck. You can develop a support network to encourage you in your writing. When considering critique groups, you might ask them what their particular approach is. Rebecca identified five different types of critique groups (and there are probably more). You’ll want to research a critique group before you join one.
- The Milford Method is feedback-focused. This is the most common approach used in MFA programs and current critique groups. The author provides a manuscript ahead of time, then listens to a round robin of feedback, without speaking.
- The Revised Milford Method provides positive feedback first, then encourages the author to speak and ask questions.
- The Amherst Writers Method asks the group to say what they liked/loved, what they disliked, and what stuck with them.
- The Mary Robinette Kowal Method focuses on how readers react to an author’s writing: were they amazed, bored, con fused, distracted?
- The Exchange of Work method is more casual, less restrictive. The group basically creates its own approach to critiquing.
How do you find a critique group? Maybe in a writing class you are taking, or workshop, or online group. You might ask people at an open mic! In any case, think about what you are looking for. A specific genre? How much time are you willing to devote to the group? You want something you can feel comfortable with—not something that will just become another chore! South Bay Writers has created various critique groups—take a look at what we have to offer. And if you have ideas of your own, let us know! Don’t be afraid to collect members with similar interests and start your own critique group!
Best of Luck!!